get candy

Wikipedia Causes Facepalms, Users Annoyed

Dear Wikipedia,

don’t do that.

wikipedia1

Users act by habit. Yours is a search-based service. You moved the search box (the single most-used element of your design) from the center left to the top right. You have a fluid design. People love 24” or even 30” monitors.

Do the math.

It’s a wonder users haven’t started a riot yet. If I were a hardcore Wikipedia user, I’d have started one for sure.

7 comments on this post

  1. Sif #1

    At least it’s not applied on greek version (yet)

  2. Ioannis Cherouvim #2

    I think that hardcore wikipedia users use the browser search (opensearch – http://www.mozilla.com/en-US/firefox/search.html)

  3. Sugar #3

    @Ioannis

    I use this particular search box all the time, hence my annoyance.

  4. karpidis #4

    @Sugar: I think by myself. I found it easy because is where usually my browser used to have search (now I have chrome so I have common address bar and search)

  5. yrizos #5

    also:

    If you examine the source, you’ll see that the search box is now structurally near the end of the page instead of very near the top. I wonder how much hassle that adds for people browsing with alternative browsers (readers and such)…

  6. Sugar #6

    @yrizos Oh I never noticed this! Good find. Weird indeed, I wonder if there’s any kind of justification behind it.

  7. sbosx #7

    Based on the human-computer interaction the most correct position for the search is top right…
    It was a big error for Wikipedia…
    However at the beginning this was a problem, but now it’s better… :P

leave your comment

sugarenia.com is wearing the Wordpress badge
valid HTML & invalid css

↑ Back to top  |  Grab the feed